Individual participant data (IPD) meta-analysis of prognostic studies: combining aggregate data and IPD

Article type
Year
Authors
Debray T1, Reitsma H2, Moons C3, Riley R4, Altman D5, Williams K6, Woolfenden S7, Hayden J8, Hooft L9
1Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care
2Julius Center
3UMC Utrecht, Julius Center
4Keele University, UK
5University of Oxford, UK
6University of Melbourne, Australia
7Sydney Children's Community Health Centre, Australia
8Dalhousie University, Canada
9Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care, The Netherlands
Abstract
Objectives: To introduce statistical methods to combine the different prediction models published for the same outcome or target population into a single prediction model based on aggregate data only, and augmented with minimal individual participant-level data (IPD).

Commonly, numerous prediction models have been developed for the same outcome or target population. For example, there are over 100 models for predicting outcome after traumatic brain injury, over 60 for breast cancer and over 40 for diabetes type 2. Rather than developing the next prediction model for a particular outcome or target population, systematic reviews of risk prediction models have become timely. These raise questions about whether, and how, previously published prediction models should and can be combined in a meta-analytical manner. Recently, innovative methods have been developed to meta-analyse (combine) previously published prediction models, given that particular aggregate data from these studies is available. Also the combination of such aggregate data plus minimal individual level participant data from one’s own single study, is illustrated.

We describe whether and how different published prediction models for the same outcome or target population can be combined into a single prediction model. We provide strategies for improving upon the generalizability and applicability of the so-derived meta-analytical prediction model, accounting for heterogeneity across the studies.